There’s perhaps no better time of year for theatrical calamity than Christmas, and Mischief’s Christmas Carol Goes Wrong arrives at Manchester’s Opera House with a welcome dose of festive mayhem and its original UK cast largely back in action. The Cornley Amateur Dramatic Society are once again determined to prove that the show must go on, although whether it should is another matter entirely.
Taking on Charles Dickens’ much-loved festive classic, the hapless company have assembled all the ingredients for a Christmas production: a familiar story, an ambitious cast and a set that appears to have been constructed without a sniff of regard for health and safety. What follows is a gloriously shambolic attempt to bring Ebenezer Scrooge’s journey to the stage, with missing performers, malfunctioning scenery, questionable casting decisions and an increasingly fragile grip on the plot.
Written by Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields, the production understands precisely where its strengths lie. The comedy is rooted in the familiar Goes Wrong formula: impeccable physical timing, elaborate practical effects and the sheer audacity of watching performers attempt to maintain their composure as everything around them falls apart. There’s an undeniable pleasure in seeing just how much can go wrong in the space of a single scene; even Scrooge himself might struggle to remain a miserable old miser in the face of such merriment.
The returning players are clearly comfortable in this chaotic territory. Matt Cavendish brings a sackfull of energy to Max, while Allie Dart’s Annie provides a welcome dose of happy-go-lucky energy amid the mounting disorder. The entire company contribute to the wonderfully dysfunctional ensemble, but it’s Sayer’s turn as the gormless but loveable Dennis that really puts the figgy in the evening’s pudding. His performance is a gift that keeps on giving, and the chemistry between the performers is particularly infectious, with everyone seemingly committed to making the situation as disastrous as possible.
Director Matt DiCarlo keeps the action suitably frantic, supported by Libby Todd’s inventive set design, which truly becomes the actors’ playground. The technical elements are particularly impressive, with lighting and sound working in tandem with the increasingly ridiculous stage business to create some genuinely inspired moments of chaos and grandeur that even The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come would have a hard time predicting.
However, for all its festive charm, the production occasionally finds itself leaning on a joke for a little longer than necessary. Some of the comic sequences would benefit from a sharper edit, with the bell chiming a little earlier on a handful of gags to preserve their punch. When the comedy is this dependent on timing, knowing precisely when to stop can be just as important as knowing when to start. There are moments when the audience has already anticipated the punchline before the production quite gets there- often adding to the humour but sometimes leaving the script feeling a little bloated; the joke equivalent of the extra roast potato that you knew you didn’t need but ate anyway, if you will.
Nevertheless, these are relatively Scrooge-like grumbles in an otherwise hugely entertaining evening. Christmas Carol Goes Wrong may not reinvent the Mischief formula, but it delivers exactly what audiences have come to expect: inventive slapstick, wonderfully executed chaos and an abundance of silliness- just the tonic for these dark winter evenings. After all, Christmas is a time for giving, and this production gives its audience plenty to enjoy.
It’s a Christmas cracker of a comedy, with more twists and turns than a turkey on a spit. Dickens might struggle to recognise his story, but Scrooge would certainly approve of the audience getting their money’s worth.
